AFTE Journal Manuscript Review Form

 

Manuscript Review Form


Title of Manuscript _________________________________________________________

Name of Reviewer ________________________________ Work Phone _______________

FA/TM Examiner          Yes           No

Your review of the attached manuscript is being requested by the author for publication in the AFTE Journal. This pre-publication procedure is very important to the quality of the journal. Please be honest and forthright in your review.

 

Manuscript Evaluation

1. Briefly, what is your evaluation of the clarity and overall effort that went into the preparation of this paper?



2. Is this paper presentable to the forensic community and would it compliment the author’s professional reputation?



3. Is this work significant? Has sound scientific methodology been utilized?



4. If possible, how could the author add to the scientific value of the manuscript? What further research or work could be done to
expand on the information presented?



5. Are pertinent references cited?



6. Has proper scientific grammar and structure been used throughout this essay?




Reviewer Recommendations


Acceptable for publication _____          Acceptable with Revisions _____          Unacceptable as Written _____

 

Manuscript Review Form (Word Doc)